About this Blog

Momfidence! cheers on commonsense parenting and sighs at the rest. How to worry less, wing it more. A.k.a. parenting by the seat of my mid-rise mom jeans.

About Paula Spencer

I'm the author of Momfidence! An Oreo Never Killed Anybody and Other Secrets of Happier Parenting, and a mom of four in Chapel Hill, North Carolina (where you can't even buy Oreos at the two wholesome groceries nearest to my home).


A rare foto in which all six Spencers face the camera! by Charles Harris

Some Kindred Blogs

How to Set Yourself Up for Messed-Up Kids

August 28, 2008
Once again I find myself apparently in the minority--this time, scratching my head over a Craigslist ad by a New York mother of four seeking a nanny. It's apparently so "extremely revelatory" that it made the rounds of the NY mom network, enough to be highlighted in a NYT article today.

The gist seems to be how brave and candid this mom is, her ad offering "a participant's critique of a particular strain of moneyed class hyperparenting that dominates in certain reaches of New York, as well as a desperate request for a certain kind of masochist."

A masochist? Taking care of four kids (not even little ones: 12, 9, and 6-y-o twins) who are in school from 8:30 to 2:15 while the mom works at home as a "painter and aspiring writer" married to a store owner? And the difficulty is....??

What goes unmentioned:
* The mom refers to her kids in this public ad as a pain-in-the-posterior. Gee, thanks Mom, we love you too.
* This is the family's "at least" 11th nanny in 12 years. Nice consistency for the kids.
* Is this how people hire nannies these days...on Craigslist? I don't live in NY and never hired a nanny, but that sounds scary to me!
* Oh, and leaving crumbs on the table is "a dealbreaker."

Okay, so the priorities are clear here.
Comments
barbie123 says...

First, let me say I absolutely love your columns, so I was so happy to find this blog! You are amazing!

As to the horrific "nanny ad": I am disgusted by this "ad" but not terribly surprised. . . especially since it was posted in Craigslist!!!. . . sounds like this mom is desperately searching for a "solution" to her "problems" rather than someone to trust her children to. . .sigh.

Keep up the great writing. . . you are speaking for a lot of us out here!

Paula says...

thanks so much for the vote of confidence!

I was wondering if this ad were some kind of New York thing...?

barbie123 says...

I'm from New York (originally) and can honestly say, this mindset (unfortunately) exists everywhere. . . . read something about "Type A" moms a while back (don't remember where) and so many of the moms featured had full-time nannies who enforced the "rules" and kept the house clean. . . . so "Type A moms" get to do everything they want without all those pesky kids getting in the way! :)

Post a comment

Your name

Website

Email (will not be published)

Subject

Comment



Send   Print