About this Blog

Momfidence! cheers on commonsense parenting and sighs at the rest. How to worry less, wing it more. A.k.a. parenting by the seat of my mid-rise mom jeans.

About Paula Spencer

I'm the author of Momfidence! An Oreo Never Killed Anybody and Other Secrets of Happier Parenting, and a mom of four in Chapel Hill, North Carolina (where you can't even buy Oreos at the two wholesome groceries nearest to my home).


A rare foto in which all six Spencers face the camera! by Charles Harris

Some Kindred Blogs

Don't Insult Your Elder's Intelligence

October 27, 2008

Your children's grandparents may or may not think the same way you do -- I hear the "no kiddings!" from here -- but nevertheless they are grownups perfectly capable of making their own decisions.

So it struck me as a bit bizarre, disrespectful, and insulting to hear a US representive urging parents to coach their kids to nag their grandparents how to vote, of all grown-up matters. Yes, you read it right. Sic them on Mima and Papaw. Beforehand, you're to say things like, "Put some urgency in your voice. Sound disappointed in them if they give you excuses."

Rep. Jan Schakowsky sums up her bright idea, "Save the deep policy discussions and simply tell their elders to "Do it for me!"

Pretty insulting to the intelligence of grandparents, who have picked many a president from their own reading of the facts without any input from the generations below them. Pretty skewed behavior to teach kids, that it's okay to wheedle and manipulate their elders (as opposed to, say, having a discussion about issues with them, if the child is capable).

Comments
Cathy says...

I think this is actually worse that schools telling kids to badger their parents about living "green"! As per one of your earlier posts, children should not be telling adults what to do, especially adults who have lived long enough to go through the ups and downs of several administrations and are intelligent enough to form their own opinion. Too many times I think young people are too swayed by the hype and don't pay enough attention to the substance of the candidates and issues anyway.

Tara says...

Have you checked out Obama's website? They are unabashedly going after children...last I checked, kids can't vote. Under the heading "Kids for Obama", they offer suggestions on getting involved in politics. It would be a good thing for him to encourage them to be part of the democratic process, to learn about the government, to have mock debates, etc....and I guess he kind of does--as long as they make sure to talk about Obama over and over again. Such hero worship is unhealthy!

One of my favorite suggestions is "Host a Senator Barack Obama House Party or sleep-over."

Here's the link:
http://my.barackobama.com/page/content/kidshome

Kate says...

Creepy..."Draw a picture of Barack Obama...for example, the Senator sitting in the White House' !!

Denise says...

Personally the whole issue of kids telling their elders what to do and how to do it is disgusting.
When my kids have tried it on me in the past, my response was and still is "I don't give a crap what other people do or want me to do, this is my life and i will make my own decisions on what is appropriate or what isn't and telling me what to do isn't appropriate behaviour."
Dicussion is then closed.

Post a comment

Your name

Website

Email (will not be published)

Subject

Comment



Send   Print